«上一篇/Previous Article|本期目录/Table of Contents|下一篇/Next Article»

《心理学探新》[ISSN:1003-5184/CN:36-1228/B]

期数:

 2023年04期

页码:

 291-297

栏目:

 理论心理学

出版日期:

 2023-08-20

文章信息/Info

Title:

 The“Fetal Movement” of Out-Watson Mr.Watson:A Historical Reassessment of Zing-Yang Kuo's Radical Behaviorism

文章编号:

1003-5184(2023)04-0291-07

作者:

 王 勇¹; 2; 王佳慧²; 鲍晨烨³; 陈 巍²; 4

 (1.厦门大学教育研究院,厦门 361005; 2.绍兴文理学院大脑、心智与教育研究中心,绍兴 312000; 3.密苏里大学心理科学系,哥伦比亚 MO 65211; 4.绍兴文理学院心理学系,绍兴 312000)

Author(s):

 Wang Yong¹; 2; Wang Jiahui²; Bao Chenye³; Chen Wei²; 4

 (1.Institute of Education,Xiamen University,Xiamen 361005; 2.Center for Brain,Mind and Education,Shaoxing University,Shaoxing 312000; 3.Department of Psychological Sciences,University of Missouri,Columbia,MO 65211,USA; 4.Department of Psychology,Shaoxing University,Shaoxing 312000)

关键词:

 郭任远;  本能;  行为主义;  行为学;  行为渐成论

Keywords:

 Zing-Yang Kuo;  instinct;  behaviorism;  praxiology;  behavior epigenetics theory

分类号:

 B8409

DOI:

 -

文献标识码:

 A

摘要:

 20世纪初期,中国青年学者郭任远凭借其激进的观点,在国际“本能论战”中有力地声援了行为主义运动。本文结合郭任远的自述和相关史料,将其反本能思想划分为三个阶段,并由此管窥郭任远激进行为主义思想的雏形及其对行为主义心理学历史进程的深刻影响。尽管如此,郭任远在本能论战中扮演的角色只是他作为“超华生”的胎动。行为学——一门多学科交叉的新科学将为郭任远开启新的学术征程,并最终推动其建构行为渐成论,进而为行为的发生发展指明认识论上的方向。

Abstract:

 In the early 20th century,Zing-Yang Kuo,a young Chinese psychologist,strongly supported the behaviorism movement in the international “instinct debate” with his radical views.Based on Kuo's self-statement and related historical materials,this paper divides his anti-instinct thought into three stages,and explores the embryonic form of Kuo's radical behaviorism thought and its profound impact on the historical process of behaviorism psychology.Nevertheless,Kuo's role in the instinct debate is only his fetal movement as an “Out-Watson Mr.Watson”.As a new interdisciplinary science,praxiology opened a new academic journey for Kuo,and finally promoted his construction of behavior epigenetics theory,and then pointed out the epistemological direction for the origin and development of behavioral ontogeny.

参考文献/References

 陈巍,王勇,郭本禹.(2021).未完结的本能:郭任远与中国本能论战.心理学报,53(4),431-444.
郭任远.(1924).我对本能运动的经过和我最近的主张.东方杂志,21(1),H1-H10.
郭任远.(1929).心理学与遗传.商务印书馆.
郭任远.(1940).我和心理学.文摘战时旬刊,(68-69),1507-1508.
胡烨,陈巍,苏彦捷,尹彬.(2022).郭任远的遗产:行为渐成论思想及其动物搏斗实验证据.应用心理学,28(6),483-499.
王勇,陈巍,郭本禹.(2023).反本能研究的复旦学派:从郭任远到蔡乐生.心理科学,46(6),1511-1517.
Boakes,R.(1984).From Darwin to behaviourism:Psychology and the minds of animals.Cambridge University Press.
Boring,E.G.(1929).A history of experimental psychology(2nd ed.).Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Cravens,H.(1978). The triumph of evolution:American scientists and the heredity-environment controversy(1900-1941).University of Pennsylvania Press.
Epstein,R.(1987).Comparative psychology as thepraxist views it.Journal of Comparative Psychology,101(3),249-253.
Freeberg,T.M.(2021).Zing-Yang Kuo and “Giving up instincts in psychology”,100 years later.Journal of Comparative Psychology,135(2),151-155.
Greenberg,G.,& Partridge,G.(2000).Prologemena to praxiology redux:The psychology of Zing-Yang Kuo.From Past to Future:Clark Papers on the History of Psychology,2,13-37.
Griffiths,P.E.(2004).Instinct in the' 50s:The British reception of Konrad Lorenz's theory of instinctive behaviour.Biology and Philosophy,19(4),609-631.
Holt,E.B.(1931).Animal drive and the learning process:An essay toward radical empiricism(Vol.1).Henry Holt & Co.
Hothersall,D.(2004).History of psychology(4th Edtion).McGraw-Hill.
James,W.(1890).The principles of psychology(Vol.2).Henry Holt & Co.
Krantz,D.L.,& Allen,D.(1967).The rise and fall of McDougall's instinct doctrine.Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences,3(4),326-338.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1921).Giving up instincts in psychology.The Journal of Philosophy,18(24),645-664.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1922).How are our instincts acquired? Psychological Review,29(5),344-365.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1924).A psychology without heredity.Psychological Review,31(6),427-448.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1929).The net result of the anti-heredity movement in psychology.Psychological Review,36(3),181-199.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1937).Prolegomena to praxiology.The Journal of Psychology,4,1-12.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1967).The dynamics of behavior development:An epigenetic view.Random House.
Kuo,Z.Y.(1970).The need for coordinated efforts in developmental studies.In L.R.Aronson,E.Tobach,D.S.Lehrman,& J.S.Rosenblatt(Eds.),Development and evolution of behavior:Essays in memory of T.C.Schneirla(pp.181-193).Freeman.
McDougall,W.(1908).An introduction to social psychology.Luce.
McDougall,W.(1921).The use and abuse of instinct in social psychology.The Journal of Abnormal Psychology and Social Psychology,16(5-6),285-333.
Spalding,D.A.(1875).Instinct and acquisition.Nature,12,507-508.
Tolman,E.C.(1922).Can instincts be given up in psychology?The Journal of Abnormal Psychology and Social Psychology,17(2),139-152.
Wang,Y.,Bao,C.,Chen,W.,& Wen,S.(2023).The forgotten militant and his enduring mission:Zing-Yang Kuo and his extraordinary years in behavioral neuroembryology(1929-1939).Journal of the History of the Neurosciences,1-22.
Watson,J.B.(1913).Psychology as the behaviorist views it.Psychological Review,20(2),158-177.
Watson,J.B.(1914).Behavior:An introduction to comparative psychology.Henry Holt & Co.
Watson,J.B.(1919).Hereditary modes of response:Instinct.In J.B.Watson(Ed.),Psychology from the standpoint of a behaviorist(pp.231-268).J B Lippincott Company.
Watson,J.B.(1926).What the nursery has to say about instincts.In C.Murchison(Ed.),Psychologies of 1925(pp.1-35).Clark University Press.
Watson,J.B.,& Lashley,K.S.(1915).Homing and related activities of birds(Vol.7).Carnegie Institution.
Whitman,C.O.(1919).The behavior of pigeons.Carnegie Institution of Washington.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:

 基金项目:教育部哲学社会科学研究重大课题攻关项目(21JZD063)。
通讯作者:陈巍,E-mail:anti-monist@163.com。

常用功能

更新日期/Last Update:  2023-08-20