«上一篇/Previous Article|本期目录/Table of Contents|下一篇/Next Article»

《心理学探新》[ISSN:1003-5184/CN:36-1228/B]

期数:

 2023年02期

页码:

 155-161

栏目:

 应用心理学

出版日期:

 2023-06-30

文章信息/Info

Title:

 Repetition Induced Truth:The Role of Fluency in the Illusory-Truth Effect

文章编号:

1003-5184(2023)02-0155-07

作者:

 金晓康

 (天津师范大学心理学部,天津 300387)

Author(s):

 Jin Xiaokang

 (Faculty of Psychology,Tianjin Normal University,Tianjin 300387)

关键词:

 重复;  加工流畅性;  虚假真实效应

Keywords:

 repetition;  fluency;  illusory-truth effect

分类号:

 B848

DOI:

 -

文献标识码:

 A

摘要:

 比起新的信息,重复接触过的信息会被认为更真实,这一效应称为虚假真实效应(Illusory-truth effect)。本文对这一效应的几种理论解释进行了比较,认为加工流畅性——认知加工过程中体验到的轻松体验——是最基础、最简洁的解释,并从加工流畅性产生的条件、原因、与情感的联系、神经基础方面进一步分析了加工流畅性的影响机制。此外,虚假真实效应非常稳健,虽然一些方法能有效降低虚假真实效应,但仍没有办法完全消除。未来应该更多地从干预的角度出发探究如何有效地避免此效应对人们的影响。

Abstract:

 Compared to new information,information that has been repeatedly exposed to it will be considered more true.This effect is called the Illusory-truth effect.This article compares several theoretical explanations of this effect,and believes that processing fluency—the relaxing experience experienced in the process of cognitive processing—is the most basic and concise explanation.In addition,we further clarify the cognitive mechanism of processing fluency in terms of when fluency occurs,why fluency equals reality,the connection between fluency and emotion,and the neural mechanism of processing fluency.In addition,the false-true effect is very robust.Although some methods can effectively reduce the repetitive effect,there is still no way to completely eliminate it.In the future,we should explore how to effectively avoid the impact of this effect on people from the perspective of intervention.

参考文献/References

 Arkes,H.R.,Hackett,C.,& Boehm,L.(1989).The generality of the relation between familiarity and judged validity.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,2(2),81-94.
Bacon,F.T.(1979).Credibility of repeated statements:Memory for trivia.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Human Learning and Memory,5(3),241.
Begg,I.M.,Anas,A.,& Farinacci,S.(1992).Dissociation of processes in belief:Source recollection,statement familiarity,and the illusion of truth.Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,121(4),446.
Brashier,N.M.,& Marsh,E.J.(2020).Judging truth.Annual Review of Psychology,71,499-515.
Brashier,N.M.,Umanath,S.,Cabeza,R.,& Marsh,E.J.(2017).Competing cues:Older adults rely on knowledge in the face of fluency.Psychology and Aging,32(4),331.
Brashier,N.,& Rand,D.(2021).Illusory truth occurs even with incentives for accuracy.Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/83m9y.
Bruffaerts,R.,Dupont,P.,Peeters,R.,De Deyne,S.,Storms,G.,& Vandenberghe,R.(2013).Similarity of fMRI activity patterns in left perirhinal cortex reflects semantic similarity between words.Journal of Neuroscience,33(47),18597-18607.
Calio,F.,Nadarevic,L.,& Musch,J.(2020).How explicit warnings reduce the truth effect:A multinomial modeling approach.Acta Psychologica,211,103185.
Calvillo,D.P.,& Harris,J.D.(2022).Exposure to headlines as questions reduces illusory truth for subsequent headlines.Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition.
Chen,T.,& Li,D.(2007).The roles of working memory updating and processing speed in mediating age-related differences in fluid intelligence.Aging,Neuropsychology,and Cognition,14(6),631-646.
Corneille,O.,Mierop,A.,& Unkelbach,C.(2020).Repetition increases both the perceived truth and fakeness of information:An ecological account.Cognition,205,104470.
DeKeersmaecker,J.,Dunning,D.,Pennycook,G.,Rand,D.G.,Sanchez,C.,Unkelbach,C.,& Roets,A.(2020).Investigating the robustness of the Illusory truth effect across individual differences in cognitive ability,need for cognitive closure,and cognitive style.Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin,46(2),204-215.
Dechêne,A.,Stahl,C.,Hansen,J.,& Wänke,M.(2009).Mix me a list:Context moderates the truth effect and the mere-exposure effect.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,45(5),1117-1122.
Dechêne,A.,Stahl,C.,Hansen,J.,& Wänke,M.(2010).The truth about the truth:A meta-analytic review of the truth effect.Personality and Social Psychology Review,14(2),238-257.
Eichenbaum,H.,Yonelinas,A.P.,& Ranganath,C.(2007).The medial temporal lobe and recognition memory.Annual Review of Neuroscience,30,123-152.
Fazio,L.K.,Brashier,N.M.,Payne,B.K.,& Marsh,E.J.(2015).Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth.Journal of Experimental Psychology General,144(5),993-1002.
Fazio,L.K.,Rand,D.G.,& Pennycook,G.(2019).Repetition increases perceived truth equally for plausible and implausible statements.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,26(5),1705-1710.
Garcia-Marques,T.,Silva,R.R.,& Mello,J.(2016).Judging the truth-value of a statement in and out of a deep processing context.Social Cognition,34(1),40-54.
Garcia-Marques,T.,Silva,R.R.,& Mello,J.(2017).Asking simultaneously about truth and familiarity may disrupt truth effects.Análise Psicológica,35(1),61-71.
Garcia-Marques,T.,Silva,R.R.,Mello,J.,& Hansen,J.(2019).Relative to what?Dynamic updating of fluency standards and between-participants illusions of truth.Acta Psychologica,195,71-79.
Garcia-Marques,T.,Silva,R.R.,Reber,R.,& Unkelbach,C.(2015).Hearing a statement now and believing the opposite later.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,56,126-129.
Gomes,C.A.,Mecklinger,A.,& Zimmer,H.(2019).The neural mechanism of fluency-based memory illusions:The role of fluency context.Learning & Memory,26(2),61-65.
Hasher,L.,Goldstein,D.,& Toppino,T.(1977).Frequency and the conference of referential validity.Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior,16(1),107-112.
Hassan,A.,& Barber,S.J.(2021).The effects of repetition frequency on the illusory truth effect.Cognitive Research:Principles and Implications,6(1),1-12.
Henderson,E.L.,Simons,D.J.,& Barr,D.J.(2021).The trajectory of truth:A longitudinal study of the illusory truth effect.Journal of Cognition,4(1).
Henson,R.,Cansino,S.,Herron,J.,Robb,W.,& Rugg,M.(2003).A familiarity signal in human anterior medial temporal cortex?Hippocampus,13(2),301-304.
Iyengar,S.S.,& Lepper,M.R.(1999).Rethinking the value of choice:A cultural perspective on intrinsic motivation.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology,76(3),349.
Jacoby,L.L.,Woloshyn,V.,& Kelley,C.(1989).Becoming famous without being recognized:Unconscious influences of memory produced by dividing attention.Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,118(2),115.
Karanian,J.M.,Rabb,N.,Wulff,A.N.,Torrance,M.G.,Thomas,A.K.,& Race,E.(2020).Protecting memory from misinformation:Warnings modulate cortical reinstatement during memory retrieval.Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,117(37),22771-22779.
Landwehr,J.R.,& Eckmann,L.(2020).The nature of processing fluency:Amplification versus hedonic marking.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,90,103997.
Lorenzoni,A.,Faccio,R.,& Navarrete,E.(2023).The influence of foreign-accented speech on credibility:Evidence from the illusory truth effect.Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/gm763.
Mayer,S.,& Landwehr,J.R.(2018).Objective measures of design typicality.Design Studies,54,146-161.
McGlone,M.S.,& Tofighbakhsh,J.(2000).Birds of a feather flock conjointly(?):Rhyme as reason in aphorisms.Psychological Science,11(5),424-428.
Nadarevic,L.,& Aßfalg,A.(2017).Unveiling the truth:Warnings reduce the repetition-based truth effect.Psychological Research,81,814-826.
Nadarevic,L.,& Erdfelder,E.(2014).Initial judgment task and delay of the final validity-rating task moderate the truth effect.Consciousness and Cognition,23,74-84.
Nadarevic,L.,Plier,S.,Thielmann,I.,& Darancó,S.(2018).Foreign language reduces the longevity of the repetition-based truth effect.Acta Psychologica,191,149-159.
Nadarevic,L.,Reber,R.,Helmecke,A.J.,& Köse,D.(2020).Perceived truth of statements and simulated social media postings:An experimental investigation of source credibility,repeated exposure,and presentation format.Cognitive Research:Principles and Implications,5(1),1-16.
Newman,E.J.,Jalbert,M.C.,Schwarz,N.,& Ly,D.P.(2020a).Truthiness,the illusory truth effect,and the role of need for cognition.Consciousness and Cognition,78,102866.
Newman,E.J.,Jalbert,M.C.,Schwarz,N.,& Ly,D.P.(2020b).Truthiness,the illusory truth effect,and the role of need for cognition.Consciousness and Cognition,78,102866.
Pan,W.,& Hu,T.-Y.(2022).More familiar,more credible?Distinguishing two types of familiarity on the truth effect using the drift-diffusion model.Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/suy2q.
Pennycook,G.,Bear,A.,Collins,E.T.,& Rand,D.G.(2020).The implied truth effect:Attaching warnings to a subset of fake news headlines increases perceived accuracy of headlines without warnings.Management Science,66(11),4944-4957.
Reber,R.,& Schwarz,N.(1999).Effects of perceptual fluency on judgments of truth.Consciousness and Cognition,8(3),338-342.
Riesthuis,P.,& Woods,J.(2023).“That's just like,your opinion,man”:The illusory truth effect on opinions.Psychological Research,1-23.
Sasaki,K.,Kobayashi,M.,Nakamura,K.,& Watanabe,K.(2023).The evasive truth:Do mere exposures at the subliminal and supraliminal levels drive the illusory truth effect?Royal Society Open Science,10(6),201791.
Schnuerch,M.,Nadarevic,L.,& Rouder,J.N.(2021).The truth revisited:Bayesian analysis of individual differences in the truth effect.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,28(3),750-765.
Scholl,S.G.,Greifeneder,R.,& Bless,H.(2014).When fluency signals truth:Prior successful reliance on fluency moderates the impact of fluency on truth judgments.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,27(3),268-280.
Schwartz,B.L.,& Metcalfe,J.(1992).Cue familiarity but not target retrievability enhances feeling-of-knowing judgments.Journal of Experimental Psychology:Learning,Memory,and Cognition,18(5),1074.
Schwarz,N.,Jalbert,M.,Noah,T.,& Zhang,L.(2021).Metacognitive experiences as information:Processing fluency in consumer judgment and decision making.Consumer Psychology Review,4(1),4-25.
Silva,R.R.,Garcia-Marques,T.,& Mello,J.(2016).The differential effects of fluency due to repetition and fluency due to color contrast on judgments of truth.Psychological Research,80,821-837.
Silva,R.R.,Garcia-Marques,T.,& Reber,R.(2017).The informative value of type of repetition:Perceptual and conceptual fluency influences on judgments of truth.Consciousness and Cognition,51,53-67.
Stanley,M.L.,Whitehead,P.S.,Marsh,E.J.,& Seli,P.(2022).Prior exposure increases judged truth even during periods of mind wandering.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,29(5),1997-2007.
Stump,A.,Rummel,J.,& Voss,A.(2022).Is it all about the feeling?Affective and(meta-)cognitive mechanisms underlying the truth effect.Psychological Research,1-25.
Udry,J.,White,S.K.,& Barber,S.J.(2022).The effects of repetition spacing on the illusory truth effect.Cognition,225,105157.
Unkelbach,C.(2007).Reversing the truth effect:Learning the interpretation of processing fluency in judgments of truth.Journal of Experimental Psychology.Learning,Memory,and Cognition,33(1),219-230.
Unkelbach,C.,Bayer,M.,Alves,H.,Koch,A.,& Stahl,C.(2011).Fluency and positivity as possible causes of the truth effect.Consciousness and Cognition,20(3),594-602.
Unkelbach,C.,& Greifeneder,R.(2013).A general model of fluency effects in judgment and decision making.In The Experience of Thinking(pp.11-32).Psychology Press.
Unkelbach,C.,& Greifeneder,R.(2018).Experiential fluency and declarative advice jointly inform judgments of truth.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,79,78-86.
Unkelbach,C.,& Rom,S.C.(2017).A referential theory of the repetition-induced truth effect.Cognition,160,110-126.
Unkelbach,C.,& Speckmann,F.(2021).Mere repetition increases belief in factually true COVID-19-related information.Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition,10(2),241-247.
Unkelbach,C.,& Stahl,C.(2009).A multinomial modeling approach to dissociate different components of the truth effect.Consciousness and Cognition,18(1),22-38.
Vogel,T.,Silva,R.R.,Thomas,A.,& Wänke,M.(2020).Truth is in the mind,but beauty is in the eye:Fluency effects are moderated by a match between fluency source and judgment dimension.Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,149(8),1587.
Wahlheim,C.N.,Alexander,T.R.,& Peske,C.D.(2020).Reminders of everyday misinformation statements can enhance memory for and beliefs in corrections of those statements in the short term.Psychological Science,31(10),1325-1339.
Wang,W.-C.,Brashier,N.M.,Wing,E.A.,Marsh,E.J.,& Cabeza,R.(2016).On known unknowns:Fluency and the neural mechanisms of illusory truth.Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience,28(5),739-746.
Wang,W.-C.,Ranganath,C.,& Yonelinas,A.P.(2014).Activity reductions in perirhinal cortex predict conceptual priming and familiarity-based recognition.Neuropsychologia,52,19-26.
Whittlesea,B.W.,& Leboe,J.P.(2003).Two fluency heuristics(and how to tell them apart).Journal of Memory and Language,49(1),62-79.
Woo,S.,Khan,M.S.,Vaz,D.,Bhavsar,D.,& Mardon,A.(2022).A review of panic buying:The mediation of illusory truth effect and persistence due to herd mentality and confirmation bias.University of Toronto Medical Journal,99(3).

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:

 通讯作者:金晓康,E-mail:xiaokangjin@outlook.com。

常用功能

更新日期/Last Update:  2023-10-30