我们的网站为什么显示成这样？

可能因为您的浏览器不支持样式，您可以更新您的浏览器到最新版本，以获取对此功能的支持，访问下面的网站，获取关于浏览器的信息：

|本期目录/Table of Contents|

 具身道德隐喻映射机制的双向性及其问题——基于具身效应“可重复性危机”的思考(PDF)

《心理学探新》[ISSN:1003-5184/CN:36-1228/B]

期数:
 2022年05期
页码:
 387-394
栏目:
 理论心理学
出版日期:
 2022-10-20

文章信息/Info

Title:
 The Bidirectional Mapping Mechanism of Embodied Moral Metaphor and Its Problems——Reflections on the “Repeatability Crisis” based on the Embodied Effect
文章编号:
1003-5184(2022)05-0387-08
作者:
 徐紫颖1; 苏佳佳2*; 叶浩生1
 (1.广州大学教育学院,广州 510006; 2.浙江师范大学心理学院,金华 321004)
Author(s):
 Xu Ziying1; Su Jiajia2; Ye Haosheng1
 (1.School of Education,Guangzhou University,Guangzhou 510006; 2.School of Psychology,Zhejiang Normal University,Jinhua 321004)
关键词:
 身体清洁;  道德概念;  隐喻映射;  具身认知
Keywords:
 physical cleanliness;  moral concepts;  metaphorical mapping;  embodied cognition
分类号:
 B8409
DOI:
 -
文献标识码:
 A
摘要:
 具身认知研究虽已取得令人瞩目的进展,但某些具身效应存在可重复性较低的问题。若长期忽视这一问题,将严重损害心理学的科学性,甚至引发一定程度的“可重复性危机”。本文从道德概念清洁隐喻的两大映射方向出发,基于两大实验类型对相关研究中可能存在的问题因素分别展开分析。未来研究应关注更注重社会互动的组织道德,将道德概念具身隐喻研究引申到现实问题中,并借助认知神经科学技术更全面地考察身体经验、情绪体验和认知加工在道德清洁隐喻加工中的作用。
Abstract:
 Although a series of achievements have been made in the study of embodied cognition,some embodied effects have the problem of low repeatability.Long-term neglect of this issue will seriously damage the scientific nature of psychology and even lead to a certain degree of “crisis of repeatability”.Starting from the two metaphorical mapping directions of cleanliness metaphors of moral concepts,this paper analyzed the possible problem factors in related research based on the two experimental types.Future research should focus on organization ethics which pay more attention to social interaction,extend the research of embodied metaphors of moral concepts to practical problems,and investigate the role of physical experience,emotional experience,and cognitive processing in moral cleansing metaphor processing more comprehensively with the help of cognitive neuroscience technology.

参考文献/References

 丁凤琴,孙逸舒.(2020).具身视角下道德概念净脏隐喻的特征、影响因素与未来展望.心理科学,32(6),1327-1332.
胡传鹏,王非,过继成思,宋梦迪,隋洁,彭凯平.(2016).心理学研究中的可重复性问题:从危机到契机.心理科学进展,24(9),1504-1518.
刘传军,廖江群.(2018).具身效应何处寻:解决可重复性危机的分析性途径.心理科学进展,26(12),2260-2271.
李莹,张灿,王悦.(2019).道德情绪在道德隐喻映射中的作用及其神经机制.心理科学进展,27(7),1224-1231.
叶浩生.(2010).具身认知:认知心理学的新取向.心理科学进展,18(5),705-710.
叶浩生.(2014).“具身”涵义的理论辨析.心理学报,46(7),1032-1042.
叶浩生,苏佳佳,苏得权.(2021).身体的意义:生成论视域下的情绪理论.心理学报,53(12),1293-1404.
殷融,苏得权,叶浩生.(2013).具身认知视角下的概念隐喻理论.心理科学进展,21(2),220-234.
Anderson,C.J.,Bahnik,S.,Barnett-Cowan,M.,Bosco,F.A.,Chandler,J.,Chartier,C.R.,…Zuni,K.(2016).Response to comment on “estimating the reproducibility of psychological science”.Science,351(6277),1037.
Casciaro,T.,Gino,F.,& Kouchaki,M.(2014).The contaminating effects of building instrumental ties how networking can make us feel dirty.Administrative Science Quarterly,59(4),705-735.
Conway,P.,& Peetz,J.(2012).When does feeling moral actually make you a better person?conceptual abstraction moderates whether past moral deeds motivate consistency or compensatory behavior.Personality & Social Psychology Bulletin,38,907-919.
Cui,G.,Errmann,A.,Kim,J.,Seo,Y.,Xu,Y.Z.,& Zhao,F.(2019).Moral effects of physical cleansing and pro-environmental hotel choices.Journal of Travel Research,(1),1-14.
Denke,C.,Rotte,M.,Heinze,H.J.,& Schaefer,M.(2016).Lying and the subsequent desire for toothpaste:Activity in the somatosensory cortex predicts embodiment of the moral-purity metaphor.Cerebral Cortex,26(2),477-484.
Dong,P.,& Lee,S.(2017).Embodiment as procedures:Physical cleansing changes goal priming effects.Journal of Experimental Psychology:General,46(4),592-605.
Douglas,M.(1966).Purity and danger:An analysis of the concepts of pollution and taboo.London:Routledge.
Earp,B.D.,Everett,J.A.C.,Madva,E.N.,& Hamlin,J.K.(2014).Out,damned spot:Can the “Macbeth Effect” be replicated?Basic and Applied Social Psychology,36(1),91-98.
Fayard,J.V.,Bassi,A.K.,Bernstein,D.M.,& Roberts,B.W.(2009).Is cleanliness next to godliness?Dispelling old wives' tales:Failure to replicate Zhong and Liljenquist(2006).Journal of Articles in Support of the Null Hypothesis,6(2),21-29.
Furukawa,Y.,Nakashima,K.,Tsukawaki,R.,& Morinaga,Y.(2021).Guilt as a signal informing us of a threat to our morality.Current Psychology,40,2122-2132.
Gang,H.F.,Lu,L.,Zhen,Z.,& Cheng,S.(2021).Moral metaphorical effect of cleanliness on immoral workplace behaviors:Environmental cleanliness or self-cleanliness?Journal of Pacific Rim Psychology,15(4),1-11.
Gambetta,D.,& Hertog,S.(2016).Engineers of Jihad:The curious connection between violent extremism and education.Princeton:Princeton University Press.
Gámez,E.,Diaz,J.,& Marrero,H.(2011).The uncertain universality of the Macbeth Effect with a Spanish sample.Spanish Journal of Psychology,14(1),156-162.
Gilchrist,P.T.,& Simone,S.(2018).The paradox of moral cleansing:When physical cleansing leads to increased contamination concerns.Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry,61,38-44.
Goldinger,S.D.,Papesh,M.H.,Barnhart,A.S.,Hansen,W.A.,& Hout,M.C.(2016).The poverty of embodied cognition.Psychonomic Bulletin & Review,23(4),959-978.
Huangfu,G.,Lv,F.,Sheng,C.,& Shi,X.(2017).Effect of workplace environment cleanliness on judgment of counterproductive work behavior.Social Behavior and Personality:An International Journal,45(4),599-604.
Jamieson,R.K.,& Pexman,P.M.(2020).Moving beyond 20 questions:We(still)need stronger psychological theory.Canadian Journal of Experimental Psychology,61,273-280.
Johnson,D.J.,Cheung,F.,& Donnellan,M.B.(2014).Does cleanliness influence moral judgments?A direct replication of Schnall,Benton,and Harvey(2008).Social Psychology,45(3),209-215.
Joosten,A.,Van Dijke,M.,Van Hiel,A.,& De Cremer,D.(2013).Feel good,do-good!On consistency and compensation in moral self-regulation.Journal of Business Ethics,123,71-84.
Kalanthroff,E.,Aslan,C.,& Dar,R.(2017).Washing away your sins will set your mind free:Physical cleansing modulates the effect of threatened morality on executive control.Cognition and Emotion,31(1),185-192.
Kim,J.,Kim,J-E.,& Park,J.(2018).Effects of physical cleansing on subsequent unhealthy eating.Marketing Letters,29(2),165-176.
Lakoff,G.,& Johnson,M.(1999).Philosophy in the flesh:The embodied mind and its challenge to western thought.Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
Lakoff,G.(2014).Mapping the brain's metaphor circuitry:Metaphorical thought in everyday reason.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,8,958.
Lee,S.W.S.,& Schwarz,N.(2011).Wiping the slate clean:Psychological consequences of physical cleansing.Current Directions in Psychological Science,20(5),307-311.
Lee,S.W.S.,& Schwarz,N.(2016).Clean-moral effects and clean-slate effects:Physical cleansing as an embodied procedure of psychological separation.In R.Duschinksy,S.Schnall,& D.Weiss(Eds.),Purity and danger now:New perspectives(pp.136-161).London:Routledge.
Lee,S.W.,Tang,H.,Wan,J.,Mai,X.,& Liu,C.(2015).A cultural look at moral purity:Wiping the face clean.Frontiers in Psychology,6,577.
Lee,S.W.S.,& Schwarz,N.(2021).Grounded procedures:A proximate mechanism for the psychology of cleansing and other physical actions.Behavioral and Brain Sciences,44,1-69.
Liljenquist,K.A.,Zhong,C.B.,& Galinsky,A.D.(2010).The smell of virtue:Clean scents promote reciprocity and charity.Psychological Science,21(3),381-383.
Lobel,T.E.,Cohen,A.,Shahin,L.K.,Malov,S.,Golan,Y.,& Busnach,S.(2015).Being clean and acting dirty:The paradoxical effect of self-cleansing.Ethics & Behavior,25(4),307-313.
Maftei,A.,& Merlici,I.A.(2021).Who wants to wash away their sins?Guilt and shame proneness and behavioral moral cleansing endorsement:A Pilot Study.Brain-Broad Research in Artificial Intelligence and Neuroscience,12(4),474-490.
Ong,S.W.X.,Tan,Y.K.,Chia,P.Y.,Lee,T.H.,Ng,O.T.,Wong,M.S.Y.,...Marimuthu,K.(2020).Air,surface environmental,and personal protective equipment contamination by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2(SARS-CoV-2)from a symptomatic patient.JAMA The Journal of the American Medical,323(16),1610-1612.
Poon,K.T.(2019).Do you reap what you sow?The effect of cyberostracism on moral impurity.Basic and Applied Social Psychology,41(2),1-15.
Sachdeva,S.,Iliev,R.,& Medin,D.L.(2009).Sinning saints and saintly sinners:The paradox of moral self-regulation.Psychological Science,20(4),523-528.
Salvo,G.,Provenzano,S.,Bello,M.D.,D'Olimpio,F.,Ottaviani,C.,& Mancini,F.(2021).Filthiness of immorality:Manipulating disgust and moral rigidity through noninvasive brain stimulation as a promising therapeutic tool for obsessive compulsive disorder.Clinical Psychological Science,10(1),127-140.
Schaefer,M.(2017).Morality and soap in engineers and social scientists:The Macbeth effect interacts with professions.Psychological Research,83(4),1-7.
Schnall,S.,Benton,J.,& Harvey,S.(2008).With a clean conscience:Cleanliness reduces the severity of moral judgments.Psychological Science,19,1219-1222.
Schnall,S.(2017).Disgust as embodied loss aversion.European Review of Social Psychology,28(1),50-94.
Siev,J.,Zuckerman,S.E.,& Siev,J.J.(2018).The relationship between immorality and cleansing:A meta-analysis of the Macbeth Effect.Social Psychology,49(5),303-309.
Tang,H.,Lu,X.,Su,R.,Liang,Z.,Mai,X.,& Liu,C.(2017).Washing away your sins in the brain:Physical cleaning and priming of cleaning recruit different brain networks after moral threat.Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience,12(7),1149-1158.
Tinbergen,N.(2010).On aims and methods of ethology.Zeitschrift für Tierpsychologie,20(4),410-433.(original work published in 1963).
Trakulpipat,A.,Wiwattanapantuwong,J.,Dhammapeera,P.,& Tuicomepee,A.(2021).“Macbeth Effect”:The link between physical cleanliness and moral judgement.Kasetsart Journal of Social Sciences,42,779-786.
van Overveld,M.,de Jong,P.J.,Peters,M.L.,van Hout,W.J.P.J.,& Bouman,T.K.(2008).An internet-based study on the relation between disgust sensitivity and emetophobia.Journal of Anxiety Disorders,22(3),524-531.
Wu,C.,& He,X.(2021).Environmental aesthetic value influences the intention for moral behavior:Changes in behavioral moral judgment.International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,8(12),6477.
Yong,E.(2012).Uncertainty shrouds psychologist's resignation.Nature News.
Zeelenberg,M.,& Pieters,R.(2006).Feeling is for doing:A pragmatic approach to the study of emotions in economic behavior.In D.De Cremer,M.Zeelenberg,& J.K.Murnighan(Eds.),Social psychology and economics(pp.117-137).New Jersey:Erlbaum.
Zhong,C.,& Liljenquist,K.(2006).Washing away your sins:Threatened morality and physical cleansing.Science,313,1451-1452.
Zhong,C.B.,Strejcek,B.,& Sivanathan,N.(2010).A clean self can render harsh moral judgment.Journal of Experimental Social Psychology,46(5),859-862.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:
 通讯作者:叶浩生,E-mail:yehaosheng0817@163.com; 苏佳佳,E-mail:sujiajia0929@163.com。
更新日期/Last Update:  2022-10-20