«上一篇/Previous Article|本期目录/Table of Contents|下一篇/Next Article»

《心理学探新》[ISSN:1003-5184/CN:36-1228/B]

期数:

 2022年01期

页码:

 20-27

栏目:

 

出版日期:

 2022-02-25

文章信息/Info

Title:

 A Comparative Study on Explicit and Implicit Moral Evaluations:Evidence from Eye-tracking

文章编号:

1003-5184(2022)01-0020-08

作者:

 陶 丹¹; 2; 3; 彭苏浩¹; 2; 3; 冷 玥¹; 2; 3; 杨诗靓⁴; 邓慧华¹; 2; 3

 (1.东南大学生物科学与医学工程学院,南京 210096; 2.儿童发展与学习科学教育部重点实验室(东南大学),南京 210096; 3.东南大学学习科学研究中心,南京 210096; 4.东南大学经济管理学院,南京 210096)

Author(s):

 Tao Dan¹; 2; 3; Peng Suhao¹; 2; 3; Leng Yue¹; 2; 3; Yang Shiliang⁴; Deng Huihua¹; 2; 3

 (1.Department of Brain and Learning Science,School of Biomedical Science and Medical Engineering,Southeast University,Nanjing 210096; 2.Key Laboratory of Child Development and Learning Science(Ministry of Education),Nanjing 210096; 3.Research Center for Learning Science,Southeast University,Nanjing 210096; 4.School of Economics and Management,Southeast University,Nanjing 210096)

关键词:

 内隐道德直觉;  外显道德推理;  伤害/关怀;  眼动追踪

Keywords:

 implicit moral intuition;  explicit moral reasoning;  harm/care;  eye-tracking

分类号:

 B842.5

DOI:

 -

文献标识码:

 A

摘要:

 为探索内隐道德直觉和外显道德推理在道德评价中的差异及其内在机制,此研究将道德图片内容限定在伤害/关心维度,同时考虑道德效价以及情绪唤醒度,利用眼动追踪技术,考察内隐和外显道德任务中,道德直觉和道德推理的眼动轨迹及其加工过程差异。眼动结果发现,外显和内隐任务中个体均对低唤醒道德图片的首次注视时间更短,对低唤醒不道德图片总注视时间更长; 内隐任务和外显任务早期自动化加工阶段的平均凝视时间无显著差异; 内隐任务中,对不道德图片比对道德图片晚期平均凝视时间更长,瞳孔直径在中晚期时显著增加。此研究结果提示无论是道德直觉过程还是道德推理过程都是意识和无意识之间的相互作用,但是道德直觉过程的加工可能存在时间上的滞后性。

Abstract:

 The present study aimed to explore the physiological mechanism and the difference between implicit moral intuition and explicit moral reasoning in moral evaluation.We adopted eye tracking technique to investigate the eye movement patterns of moral intuition and moral reasoning influenced by moral valence and emotional arousal during implicit and explicit moral tasks limited to harm/care domain.The eye tracking results revealed that the time to first fixation were shorter on low-arousal moral pictures and longer fixation time on low-arousal immoral pictures in both tasks; and there was no significant difference in dwell time between explicit and implicit tasks at the early stage; in implicit task,the dwell time was longer on immoral pictures than on moral pictures at the late stage,besides,individuals had greater pupil dilation at the middle and late stages.These results support that both moral intuition and moral reasoning involve interactions between consciousness and unconsciousness,however,moral intuition may have a lag in time.

参考文献/References

 魏子晗,李兴珊.(2015).决策过程的追踪:基于眼动的证据.心理科学进展,23(12),2029-2041.
Abele,A.E.,& Wojciszke,B.(2014).Communal and agentic content in social cognition.A dual perspective model.Advances in Experimental Social Psychology,50(50),195-255.
Armstrong,T.,& Olatunji,B.O.(2012).Eye tracking of attention in the affective disorders:A meta-analytic review and synthesis.Clinical Psychology Review,32(8),704-723.
Bacha-Trams,M.,Glerean,E.,Dunbar,R.,Lahnakoski,J.M.,Ryyppo,E.,Sams,M.,& Jaaskelainen,I.P.(2017).Differential inter-subject correlation of brain activity when kinship is a variable in moral dilemma.Scientific Reports,7(1),14244.
Bangee,M.,Harris,R.A.,Bridges,N.,Rotenberg,K.J.,& Qualter,P.(2014).Loneliness and attention to social threat in young adults:Findings from an eye tracker study.Personality and Individual Differences,63,16-23.
Buon,M.,Seara-Cardoso,A.,& Viding,E.(2016).Why(and how)should we study the interplay between emotional arousal,theory of mind,and inhibitory control to understand moral cognition?Psychonomic Bulletin and Review,23(6),1660-1680.
Cameron,C.D.,Payne,B.K.,Sinnott-Armstrong,W.,Scheffer,J.A.,& Inzlicht,M.(2017).Implicit moral evaluations:A multinomial modeling approach.Cognition,158,224-241.
Critchley,H.D.,Tang,J.,Glaser,D.,Butterworth,B.,& Dolan,R.J.(2005).Anterior cingulate activity during error and autonomic response.Neuroimage,27(4),885-895.
Crone,D.L.,Bode,S.,Murawski,C.,& Laham,S.M.(2018).The socio-moral image database(smid):A novel stimulus set for the study of social,moral and affective processes.PLoS One,13(1),e0190954.
Cui,F.,Wu,S.,Wu,H.,Wang,C.,Jiao,C.,& Luo,Y.(2017).Altruistic and self-serving goals modulate behavioral and neural responses in deception.Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience,13(1),63-71.
Cushman,F.(2012).Action,outcome,and value:A dual-system framework for morality.Personality and Social Psychology Review,17(3),273-292.
Fede,S.J.,& Kiehl,K.A.(2019).Meta-analysis of the moral brain:Patterns of neural engagement assessed using multilevel kernel density analysis.Brain Imaging and Behavior,14(2),534-547.
Fiedler,S.,& Gl?ckner,A.(2015).Attention and moral behavior.Current Opinion in Psychology,6,139-144.
Garon,M.,Forgeot d’Arc,B.,Lavallee,M.M.,Estay,E.V.,& Beauchamp,M.H.(2018).Visual encoding of social cues contributes to moral reasoning in autism spectrum disorder:An eye-tracking study.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,12,409.
Garon,M.,Forgeot d’Arc,B.,Lavallée,M.M.,Estay,E.V.,& Beauchamp,M.H.(2018).Visual encoding of social cues contributes to moral reasoning in autism spectrum disorder:An eye-tracking study.Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,12,409.
Gray,K.,Young,L.,& Waytz,A.(2012).Mind perception is the essence of morality.Psychological Inquiry,23(2),101-124.
Greene,J.,& Haidt,J.(2002).How(and where)does moral judgment work?Trends Cognitive Sciences,6(12),517-523.
Ham,J.,& Kees,V.D.B.(2010).On unconscious morality:The effects of unconscious thinking on moral decision making.Social Cognition,28(1),74-83.
Harenski,C.L.,Antonenko,O.,Shane,M.S.,& Kiehl,K.A.(2010).A functional imaging investigation of moral deliberation and moral intuition.Neuroimage,49,2707-2716.
Huang,J.,Fan,X.,Zhang,B.,& Huang,Y.(2021).Can negative emotion of task-irrelevant working memory representation affect its attentional capture?A study of eye movements.Acta Psychologica Sinica,53(1).
Juan Yang,L.G.,& Mingming,Qi.(2014).Gender differences in neural mechanisms underlying moral judgment of disgust:A functional mri study.Journal of Behavioral and Brain Science,4,214-222.
Kahane,G.(2015).Sidetracked by trolleys:Why sacrificial moral dilemmas tell us little(or nothing)about utilitarian judgment.Social Neuroscience,10(5),551-560.
Kaspar,K.,Krapp,V.,& Konig,P.(2015).Hand washing induces a clean slate effect in moral judgments:A pupillometry and eye-tracking study.Scientific Reports,5,10471.
Lotto,L.,Manfrinati,A.,& Sarlo,M.(2014).A new set of moral dilemmas:Norms for moral acceptability,decision times,and emotional salience.Journal of Behavioral Decision Making,27(1),57-65.
Marechal,M.A.,Cohn,A.,Ugazio,G.,& Ruff,C.C.(2017).Increasing honesty in humans with noninvasive brain stimulation.Proceedings of the Natlional Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,114(17),4360-4364.
Moll,J.,& de Oliveira-Souza,R.(2007).Moral judgments,emotions and the utilitarian brain.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,11(8),319-321.
Paxton,J.M.,& Greene,J.D.(2010).Moral reasoning:Hints and allegations.Trends in Cognitive Sciences,2(3),511-527.
Schein,C.,& Gray,K.(2017).The theory of dyadic morality:Reinventing moral judgment by redefining harm.Personality and Social Psychology,1-39.
Sinnottarmstrong,W.,& Wheatley,T.(2014).Are moral judgments unified?Philosophical Psychology,27,451-474.
Skulmowski,A.,Bunge,A.,Kaspar,K.,& Pipa,G.(2014).Forced-choice decision-making in modified trolley dilemma situations:A virtual reality and eye tracking study.Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience,8,426.
Tasso,A.,Sarlo,M.,& Lotto,L.(2017).Emotions associated with counterfactual comparisons drive decision-making in footbridge-type moral dilemmas.Motivation and Emotion,41,410-418.
Urry,H.L.,Reekum,C.M.,Johnstone,T.,& Davidson,R.J.(2009).Individual differences in some(but not all)medial prefrontal regions reflect cognitive demand while regulating unpleasant emotion.Neuroimage,47,852-863.
Wei,Z.-H.,& Li,X.(2015).Decision process tracing:Evidence from eye-movement data.Advances in Psychological Science,23,2029.
Yoder,K.J.,Harenski,C.,Kiehl,K.A.,& Decety,J.(2015).Neural networks underlying implicit and explicit moral evaluations in psychopathy.Translational Psychiatry,5(8),e625.

备注/Memo

备注/Memo:

 基金项目:国家自然科学基金项目(31500881),中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助(2242020K40076),江苏省高校研究生科研创新项目(KYCX17_0159)。
通讯作者:冷玥,E-mail:lengyue@seu.edu.cn。

常用功能

更新日期/Last Update:  1900-01-01